"I suggest you start
telling people outside the Church they are going to Hell and that Catholic
sinners are going to Purgatory"
Answer / Resources:
[click link(s) below, as applicable]
First, stating such
things as absolutes doesn't seem to allow for any change (e.g. while
non-Catholic can't be saved outside the Church, a person who is not
Catholic will NOT necessarily go
to hell because they can convert at any time). Absolutes without full
explanations can confuse people and make them feel that there is no hope (e.g.
if you tell someone that they will go to hell for murder, it could be very true,
but it is also true that they can repent and avoid going to hell...so saying
someone will go to hell for murder isn't a complete picture all by itself).
Second, I would
caution against saying where any particular person will end up after their death. We cannot know
for certain (outside of canonization or a special revelation from God) where
anyone will end up as that is for God alone to judge. It seems safest to say
that sinful Catholics "MAY" end up in purgatory "IF" they are saved and that
non-Catholics are (objectively speaking) in a gravely dangerous situation. We
cannot say with certainty that someone who is not Catholic will go to hell,
since repentance/conversion can come even a moment before one's death, even
if it is not apparent to others. Nor can
we say with certainty whether someone who is saved will go to purgatory (it may
be likely, but not certain). So we must be careful not to make such statements.
Again, keep in mind that it is God's place to judge, not ours.
Lastly, on behalf of
the deceased, it is 'safest'/most charitable to assume they are in purgatory so
we may be inspired to pray for them.
Reminder: We make no guarantee whatsoever regarding any item herein. Items herein may be the opinions of their authors and do not necessarily reflect our views.
All applicable items may be subject to change at any time without notice. Utilize any link(s) appearing on this page at your own risk.
For more terms information, see "Important Notice" below.
** Page may contain third party advertisement(s)
in any location.
We are not responsible for content. Not an endorsement.
We make no guarantee whatsoever regarding any
item herein. Items herein may be the opinions of their authors
and do not necessarily reflect our views. Items herein may not be comprehensive,
may not be current, may be subject to change at any time without notice, may not
apply to all persons, may be subjective / debatable / erroneous, etc.
Interpretation and application of items herein should not be contrary to the
perennial, official teaching of the Roman Catholic Church. Do not take items out
of context. Do not inflict harm on yourself or others, break laws, take
unsuitable/incautious or inappropriate/drastic actions, or take figurative items
literally. Inclusion of any item herein does not imply endorsement. Clicking on a third
party link leaves our site. We are not responsible for any third party site /
product / service / content / etc. Third parties may not be Catholic.
For terms information,
MyCatholicSource.com ™, MyCatholicSource.org ™,
and other indicated & related items are trademarks of B.F.S.
MyCatholicSource.com, BFSApps, and BFSMedia are divisions of B.F.S.